
A Comet, A Calling, A Form of Immortality
Dr. Alan Hale reflects on his childhood in Alamogordo, a lifelong passion for the night sky, and the remarkable July 1995 night in Cloudcroft when he discovered one of the most celebrated comets of the 20th century—Comet Hale-Bopp.
"Most people who know me well will say that I haven't grown up yet."
Dr. Alan Hale says that with humor, but it reveals something essential: his life has been guided by curiosity—and by a willingness to look up long enough to notice what others might miss.
Born in Tachikawa, Japan, outside Tokyo, while his father was stationed there as a career Air Force officer, Alan moved to Holloman Air Force Base near Alamogordo just months later.
Two years after the move, his father retired from the Air Force and continued working in civil service at the base, allowing the family to remain in Alamogordo for the rest of Alan's childhood. Alan graduated from Alamogordo High School in 1976.
His childhood had both joy and hardship. His parents divorced when he was 5, remarried when he was 8 and separated again during his teenage years. He had two older brothers: Wayne, who was killed in a car accident in 1968 at age 20, and Barry, who now resides in Arizona. Both served in the military—Wayne in the Army and Barry in the Navy.
Alan describes himself as heavyset as a child—"and still am"—but athletics became part of his life in junior high and high school. He played football as a backup offensive lineman and threw discus and shot put, winning a few ribbons along the way. But the defining influence came early.
Hooked Almost Immediately
When Alan was in first grade, his father checked out astronomy books from the Holloman library, hoping to channel his son's scholastic promise into outside interests.
"I was hooked almost immediately," Alan says.
He read about various phenomena—including comets—and wanted to observe them all. Shortly after getting his first telescope, he read an article in Sky & Telescope about the bright comet Tago-Sato-Kosaka that would be visible in late January and early February 1970. Incidentally, it would be the first comet ever observed from space by an artificial spacecraft.
On the evening of Feb. 2, Alan's friend Mark Bakke came over with his telescope. Armed with the information from the article, they soon spotted it: a "fuzzball" in binoculars and their telescopes, dimly visible to the unaided eye. Hale followed it every night for the next week.
A month and a half later, the very bright comet Bennett appeared as a splendid naked-eye object in the morning sky. With two bright comets appearing in such quick succession after he first started observing, Alan got the idea that bright comets came by quite frequently.
Comets are not frequent. Alan had simply begun observing at a very fortuitous time for bright comets. But by the time he learned that, though, he was already hooked.
From that point on, he tried to observe every comet bright enough to see with the equipment he had. He thought it would be "cool" to discover a comet, especially since, by tradition, comets are named for their discoverers.
Alan and Mark shared an interest in astronomy and the two often observed together—including witnessing a total solar eclipse in Manitoba in 1979. Tragically, Mark was killed in a gunshot accident in 1984 at age 27, a loss that stayed with Alan.
The Long Hunt
Alan began his systematic search for new comets during his graduate school years from 1986–1992, as part of his broader observing program.
Many people spend years, even decades, searching for comets and never find anything. But some—including a couple of Alan's friends—made multiple discoveries. The fact that some individuals did succeed helped keep him going.
Alan recalls one major disappointment in early 1989 when clouds moved in at exactly the wrong time. He would have been hunting in a region of the sky where a comet was discovered just hours later by an observer in Japan.
In early 1992, after several hundred hours of unsuccessful searching—and in light of increasing workload and family responsibilities—Alan ceased his comet hunting efforts.
Then came July 1995.
During New Mexico's monsoon season, clear nights can be scarce. Alan's family had moved into their residence near Cloudcroft in March of that year. He had been following known comets for many years as part of his regular observing program, and his standard practice was to try to observe them about once a week. That July, he was following two comets.
On Friday, July 21, he spent the day in Albuquerque attending a meeting of the Space and Robotics '96 conference organizing committee. Afterward, Alan made the long drive back to Cloudcroft, arriving around midnight. The sky was surprisingly clear, and he hurriedly prepared to observe—only to see the sky cloud over within those few minutes.
Saturday, July 22, was dry and clear all day, and he planned to observe that night. At the time, he was writing a weekly column on astronomy and space for the Alamogordo Daily News and planned to write about one of the two comets the following week.
Little did he know he was about to walk into history.
The Discovery Night
Alan initially observed the first of the two known comets he was following and finished just before midnight. He had an hour or so to wait before the second rose high enough above the house to observe. Since the night was gorgeously clear, he decided to pass the time by observing objects in and around the constellation Sagittarius.
When he turned the telescope toward the star cluster M70, he immediately saw a dimmer, fuzzy object within the same field of view. Alan had observed M70 under somewhat similar circumstances a couple of weeks earlier and had not noticed any such object nearby, so this was attention-worthy.
He confirmed he was indeed observing M70—he was. He checked the star atlas—no known object was shown in that location. After quickly sketching the object relative to the surrounding star field, he went inside and checked various catalogs.
There were no known objects in that location.
Alan logged onto the International Astronomical Union's Central Bureau for Astronomical Telegrams and ran its comet identification program. There were no known comets in that location.
Alan was almost—but not entirely—sure he had found an unknown comet. He emailed the director and assistant director of the Central Bureau. Alan already had a relationship with the directors: over the previous few years, he had worked with them and had confirmed and disconfirmed several reported comet discoveries. He was a trusted, known quantity.
After sending those emails, he went back outside to check the object. It had been roughly 45 minutes since he'd first seen the object. When viewing it again, it had clearly moved against the background stars.
It was undoubtedly a previously unknown comet.
After sending a second email to the Central Bureau, he woke his then-wife and asked if she wanted to take a look at "Comet Hale." She did, and also woke her sister Alice, who was visiting at the time.
When his wife woke his 8-year-old son, Zachary, to ask whether he wanted to see "Daddy's comet," he muttered something about "Dad and his spacey stuff again" and went back to sleep.
Alan followed the comet for three more hours before it set behind the trees in the southwest. He also took time to observe the second of the known comets he had initially set out to observe.
Before heading inside, he looked up and said a quick but sincere "Thank you!" to the sky.
With three hours of positional measurements, he emailed them to the Central Bureau, went inside to write a fresh-in-his-mind account of the discovery for posterity and then tried—rather unsuccessfully—to get some sleep.
Meeting Thomas Bopp
When he rolled out of bed around 8 a.m., Alan checked his email and found a note of congratulations from Brian Marsden, then director of the Central Bureau, along with the question: "Did you ask Thomas Boppe [sic] in Glendale to confirm it for you? He seems to have done so."
Alan replied that he didn't know any such person.
He was not surprised that someone else had picked up the comet around the same time—anyone observing M70 should have noticed it. Alan later learned other individuals claimed to have come across it around that time, but either never followed up or found it after he and Tom reported it.
Alan and Tom made several joint appearances. At the Enchanted Skies Star Party in Socorro in September 1995, they held their first public meeting. They remained in occasional touch after the Hale-Bopp comet faded from view, and Hale saw Tom for the last time at a conference in Tucson in mid-2016. Tom passed away a year and a half later.
It is unclear which one of them saw Hale-Bopp first. Neither noted the exact time he first spotted it, and, by comparing notes, they determined their discoveries were within 5 minutes of each other. Alan's report reached the Central Bureau first, but he had an advantage: He could email from home, whereas Tom was in the desert 90 miles away and had to drive back before he could report it.
Alan is clear on one point.
"Our names both belonged on it, and I am completely comfortable with that."
Songs of the Moment
While getting ready to observe the sky on the night he discovered Comet Hale-Bopp, Alan Hale listened to two songs from R.E.M.'s album "Automatic for the People"—"Everybody Hurts" and "Man on the Moon."
Last year, after writing a 30-year-anniversary reminiscence of the discovery, Alan found someone who knew the band's members. That individual contacted the band on his behalf. Alan learned they were unaware of the role they played in the Hale-Bopp discovery and were delighted to learn of it.
Next month: In part two of this story, we explore the scientific breakthroughs of Hale-Bopp, the global attention it generated, Alan's experiences navigating international media and science diplomacy and his reflections on his legacy—including what it means to know that 2,400 years from now, people may still speak his name when a bright comet returns.
